Study Guide Instructor view

Automated Systems

Teaching notes for Lesson 3.11, with controls for presenting it.

Keep this page on your own screen. Share only the lesson window. The lesson window holds no teaching notes, so sharing it cannot show them.

Presenting

  1. Open the lesson in its own window and share that window, not this one.
  2. Use Next and Previous here, or the lesson’s own, to move through the lesson. Next reveals one thing at a time: the next idea, or the answer to the question on screen, then the next step. Previous takes the last reveal back. The line below says what is on screen and what Next will show.
  3. Reveal hints and answers when the class is ready, and reset a demonstration before using it again.

The controls need JavaScript and a browser that supports BroadcastChannel. Without them, open the lesson in presentation mode and use its own controls.

The two windows talk to each other only inside this browser, on this device. Nothing is sent to a server, and no account is needed. A second device (a phone or another tablet) cannot follow the lesson window yet.

Lesson plan

Level
Intermediate
Time
About 90 minutes; the steps below add up to 90

Pupils begin with a greenhouse nobody is watching and work out that it must measure, decide and act, in a loop, before sensor, microprocessor and actuator are named. They then judge automation in a bottling line, a driverless shuttle, a dry farm, a controller, corridor lights and a volcano monitor, always asking what is gained and what can go wrong in that place. The lesson ends with a written judgement and an explanation of a system, so you can see whether pupils reason from the scenario’s facts rather than saying automation is always good or always bad.

Objectives

  • Describe how sensors, a microprocessor and actuators work together in an automated system, as a repeating sense, process and act loop
  • Identify the sensor, the microprocessor’s decision and the actuator in a given automated system
  • Describe advantages and disadvantages of an automated system in industry, transport, agriculture, weather, gaming, lighting and science scenarios
  • Evaluate whether automating a given task is a good idea, and justify the judgement with reasons from the scenario

Before the lesson

  • Draw the sense, process, act loop as a circle on the board with three empty boxes; fill them in with the greenhouse parts and reuse the circle for every system.
  • Mini whiteboards for think questions and show-me answers.
  • Prepare two columns on the board, for and against, to collect advantages and risks for each scenario.
  • This lesson is 90 minutes: the natural break is after the dry-farm step.
  • Have the worked judgement steps from the lesson (say what it would do, weigh benefits, weigh risks, decide with a condition) ready to display.

Steps

  1. Introduction Opening

    On screen: the lesson’s title, module and number; Next adds its objectives and key terms, as the lesson page lists them; Next again begins the first step.

    Objectives on screen

    • Describe how sensors, a microprocessor and actuators work together in an automated system, as a repeating sense, process and act loop
    • Identify the sensor, the microprocessor’s decision and the actuator in a given automated system
    • Describe advantages and disadvantages of an automated system in industry, transport, agriculture, weather, gaming, lighting and science scenarios
    • Evaluate whether automating a given task is a good idea, and justify the judgement with reasons from the scenario

    Purpose: Pupils begin with a greenhouse nobody is watching and work out that it must measure, decide and act, in a loop, before sensor, microprocessor and actuator are named. They then judge automation in a bottling line, a driverless shuttle, a dry farm, a controller, corridor lights and a volcano monitor, always asking what is gained and what can go wrong in that place. The lesson ends with a written judgement and an explanation of a system, so you can see whether pupils reason from the scenario’s facts rather than saying automation is always good or always bad.

  2. 1. A greenhouse nobody is watching Think 10 min

    Purpose: Pupils list what a greenhouse would have to do for itself, so that measure, decide and act, in a repeating loop, are reasoned out before the parts are named.

    Ask

    • List the jobs the greenhouse would have to do, in order.
    • Which would need a measuring device, which a decision and which something to move?
    • Which part decides that the vent must be opened?

    Responses to expect

    • Measure the temperature, decide whether it is too hot, open a vent or fan
    • Measuring: sensor; deciding: microprocessor; moving: actuator
    • The microprocessor, which compares the reading with the limit

    Misconceptions to challenge

    • A learner may believe: “The temperature sensor decides, because it knows how hot it is.” Respond: The sensor only measures and reports. Ask what compares the reading with a limit.
    • A learner may believe: “The actuator decides, because it is the one that moves.” Respond: The actuator only does what it is told. Ask what sends it the signal.
    • A learner may believe: “The system does each job once and stops.” Respond: The temperature changes, so the loop never stops while the system is on.

    On the board or with the pen

    • Write measure, decide, act in the loop and add sensor, microprocessor, actuator once pupils have reasoned the jobs.

    What learners should notice

    • Three different jobs need three different kinds of part.
    • The loop repeats.

    Checking understanding: Pupils list the jobs on whiteboards; the who-decides check shows who has separated measuring from deciding.

    Depending on the answers

    • If pupils choose the sensor as the decider: ask whether the thermometer in a room ever opens a window by itself.
    • If answers are secure: ask what could go wrong if the system could measure but not act.

    English as an additional language

    • Check measure, decide and act with three verbs and a picture.

    Discussion pause: Thirty seconds of silent listing before pairs compare.

    In the lesson window

    • Think it through: Imagine the greenhouse had to protect the plants by itself. List the jobs it would have to do, in order, and say which would need a measuring device, which would need a decision, and which would need something to move.
    • Check your understanding: In the greenhouse, which part decides that the vent must be opened?
  3. 2. Which part does which job? Explain 12 min

    Purpose: Pupils find the three parts in a street light, then sort descriptions and decide what counts as automated, so that the sense, process, act pattern becomes a test.

    Ask

    • Which part measures, which decides, which acts in the street light?
    • Which of the three does each description fit?
    • Which of the three listed things is an automated system?

    Responses to expect

    • Light sensor, microprocessor or control circuit, the switch for the lamp
    • Sensor, microprocessor or actuator according to the description
    • The heater with a thermostat that switches itself on when the room is too cold

    Misconceptions to challenge

    • A learner may believe: “A wall thermometer that a person reads is automated.” Respond: It senses, but a person decides and acts. Ask which parts of the loop are missing.
    • A learner may believe: “A fan switched on by hand is automated.” Respond: There is no sensor and no decision here: a person does it all.
    • A learner may believe: “An automated system is clever and aware.” Respond: Use the misconception callout: it only follows its program and responds to what its sensors can measure.

    On the board or with the pen

    • Write a three-box test: sensor? decision? actuator? and tick each device pupils test.

    What learners should notice

    • Automated means sense, decide and act without a person in the loop.
    • The test is the three parts, not the use of a machine.

    Checking understanding: The name-the-part table and is-it-automated check; ask pupils to say which of the three parts is missing from each wrong option.

    Depending on the answers

    • If pupils choose the thermometer: ask who does the deciding and acting and what the system lacks.
    • If answers are secure: ask for a new example from home and run the three-box test on it.

    Support

    • Provide the three parts as cards to attach to each description.

    English as an additional language

    • Check automated, thermostat and switch; show the street light picture.

    In the lesson window

    • Check your understanding: Which of these is an automated system?
  4. 3. Industry: the bottling line Predict 12 min

    Purpose: Pupils compare an automated bottling line with people doing the job, then apply cost and scale to a small bakery, so that advantages are always weighed against the business.

    Ask

    • Give two things the automated line does better and two things that could go wrong.
    • Should the bakery with three staff buy the fully automated line?
    • What in the story shows whether it is a good choice?

    Responses to expect

    • Runs day and night, fills every bottle the same; expensive, a breakdown stops everything
    • Not yet: the saving at 100 loaves a day is small next to the cost and a breakdown could stop all baking
    • The scale and cost of this business

    Misconceptions to challenge

    • A learner may believe: “Automation always saves money, however small the business.” Respond: Savings depend on how much is made. Ask how many loaves the line would need to make to repay its cost.
    • A learner may believe: “An automated line can never make bread as well as a person.” Respond: The question gives no evidence the quality would be worse; ask what in the story suggests it is a poor choice.
    • A learner may believe: “Because the line is expensive, it can never be worth it.” Respond: For 6,000 bottles an hour it might be; scale matters.

    On the board or with the pen

    • Write two columns, better and worse, for the bottling line and add the bakery’s numbers beside the cost.

    What learners should notice

    • Advantages are real, but a judgement compares them with cost and scale.

    Checking understanding: Show-me answers for bakery-decision; ask pupils for the fact in the question that supports their choice.

    Depending on the answers

    • If pupils choose ‘always buy’: ask them to work out how long 100 loaves a day takes to repay the cost.
    • If answers are secure: ask what the owner could do instead of buying the whole line.

    English as an additional language

    • Check advantage, disadvantage and cost; use the two columns.

    Discussion pause: Pairs list two good and two bad points before sharing.

    In the lesson window

    • Think it through: Compare this with a team of people filling the bottles. Give two things the automated line could do better, and two things that could go wrong or be a disadvantage.
    • Apply it: A bakery with three staff makes about 100 loaves a day. The owner is offered a fully automated production line that would cost more than the bakery earns in several years. Which judgement is best?
  5. 4. Transport: the driverless shuttle Predict 10 min

    Purpose: Pupils trace what a driverless train must do if a person is on the track and what happens if the forward sensor fails, so that a safety judgement names the remaining risk.

    Ask

    • What must the system do when a person falls on to the track?
    • What could go wrong if the forward sensor has failed?
    • Is the manager right that an automated shuttle will never have an accident?

    Responses to expect

    • Detect the person, decide to stop and brake, faster than a person could
    • The microprocessor would not know, so the brakes would not act
    • No: faulty sensors and unplanned situations can still cause harm

    Misconceptions to challenge

    • A learner may believe: “Computers do not make mistakes, so automation is perfectly safe.” Respond: The computer only does what its program and sensor readings tell it. Ask what happens if a sensor gives a wrong reading.
    • A learner may believe: “Automated trains are always less safe than human drivers.” Respond: There is no evidence for always. Ask which advantages of automation have been met.

    On the board or with the pen

    • Draw the loop for the shuttle and put a cross on the sensor to show where the failure would break it.

    What learners should notice

    • A good reply keeps the advantage and names the remaining risk.

    Checking understanding: Show-me answers for never-an-accident; ask pupils which part of the reply keeps the advantage and which names the risk.

    Depending on the answers

    • If pupils choose ‘manager is right’: ask what the microprocessor knows if the sensor lies.
    • If answers are secure: ask what backup could reduce the risk.

    English as an additional language

    • Check driverless, obstacle and backup with a track picture.

    In the lesson window

    • Think it through: A person has fallen on to the track ahead of a train. What must the system be able to do? And what could go wrong if the sensor that looks ahead has failed?
    • Apply it: A manager says: “The shuttle is automated, so it will never have an accident.” What is the best response?
  6. 5. Agriculture and weather: places and times nobody wants to be Predict 12 min

    Purpose: Pupils see what irrigation and a hill-top weather station do that people cannot, and what a faulty sensor would cause, so that the risk of a single sensor is reduced by checking.

    Ask

    • What do these systems do that a person with a timetable could not easily do?
    • What would go wrong if a moisture sensor broke or ice covered a temperature sensor?
    • Which action best reduces the risk of a single faulty moisture sensor?

    Responses to expect

    • Work at any hour, in every field at once, in places nobody wants to be, watering only when needed
    • A wrong reading would lead to wrong action
    • Use several sensors in each field and have a person check regularly

    Misconceptions to challenge

    • A learner may believe: “Remove all the sensors and water on a fixed timetable.” Respond: That takes away the advantage of watering only when needed. Ask which part of the loop would be lost.
    • A learner may believe: “A more powerful microprocessor fixes a faulty reading.” Respond: A faster decision does not fix a wrong reading. Ask where the problem starts.
    • A learner may believe: “An automatic weather station can judge which weather is unusual.” Respond: The system only measures and records what it is programmed to; people decide what the readings mean.
    • A learner may believe: “A remote weather station needs no power, repair or visit.” Respond: Remote equipment needs power and checking, as when ice covers a sensor.

    On the board or with the pen

    • Add a ‘what if the sensor is wrong?’ branch to the loop and write comparing several sensors beside it.

    What learners should notice

    • A wrong reading is a sensor problem, so the fix is at the sensor.
    • Automation’s strength in remote places is continuous readings.

    Checking understanding: Show-me answers for reduce-sensor-risk and why-weather-station; ask pupils what the wrong options leave unsolved.

    Depending on the answers

    • If pupils choose a faster microprocessor: ask whether a quicker decision from a wrong reading is better.
    • If answers are secure: ask what a person adds that sensors cannot.

    Stretch

    • Design a check that would tell the system a single moisture sensor is giving a reading different from its neighbours.

    English as an additional language

    • Check irrigation, valve and remote with the farm picture.

    Discussion pause: Pupils list benefits and risks silently before the apply questions.

    In the lesson window

    • Think it through: What do these two systems do that a farmworker with a timetable, or a person living on the hill, could not easily do? And what would go wrong if a moisture sensor broke, or if ice covered the weather station’s temperature sensor?
    • Apply it: Which action best reduces the risk to the farm’s crops from a single faulty moisture sensor?
    • Apply it: What is the strongest reason to use an automatic weather station on the remote hill, rather than staff?
  7. 6. Gaming, lighting and science Discover 14 min

    Purpose: Pupils name a benefit and a limit for three more systems, then apply the idea to corridor lights in a stairwell, a volcano monitor and a motion controller, so that the question ‘what if it gets it wrong, here?’ becomes habit.

    Ask

    • For the controller, the corridor lights and the volcano monitor, name a benefit and a situation in which it fails.
    • Is the stairwell lighting a good idea, and what should be added?
    • What does the volcano lake colour show?
    • What is the strongest advantage of the motion controller for a player who finds buttons difficult?

    Responses to expect

    • Controller: natural movements, may misread; lights: save electricity, may miss someone; monitor: constant data, cannot sense what it is not built for
    • It saves electricity, but a stairwell is a safety risk, so a delay and manual override make sense
    • An automated system only reacts to what it was built for, so people are still needed to notice the unexpected
    • Natural arm movements replace buttons, though it needs space and can misread some movements

    Misconceptions to challenge

    • A learner may believe: “Lights that switch themselves cannot fail.” Respond: A sensor may not notice someone. Ask what risk that creates on a stairwell.
    • A learner may believe: “Anything automated costs more to run than it saves.” Respond: Movement-sensing lights usually save electricity; ask what is riskier in this scenario.
    • A learner may believe: “The microprocessor is faulty if it did not notice the colour change.” Respond: It can only use the readings it receives. Ask which sensor would have measured colour.
    • A learner may believe: “The actuators should have reported the change.” Respond: Actuators act; they do not collect information.
    • A learner may believe: “The controller makes the game easier to win or lets it run without a CPU.” Respond: The controller senses movement; the game still needs a CPU.

    On the board or with the pen

    • Make a three-row table: system, one benefit, one limit, filled as pupils answer, with the stairwell’s ‘where’ underlined.

    What learners should notice

    • Each judgement includes a real benefit and a limit tied to the place.
    • A system cannot notice what it was not built to sense.

    Checking understanding: Show-me answers on corridor-lights, volcano-unexpected and controller-misread; ask pupils to give the fact in the question that decides.

    Depending on the answers

    • If pupils choose ‘no drawbacks’ for the lights: ask what happens on the stairs in the dark if the sensor misses someone.
    • If answers are secure: ask what sensor the volcano system would need to notice the lake changing colour.

    Support

    • Offer a frame: A benefit is ___. A limit is ___, because ___.

    English as an additional language

    • Check sensor, override and misread; use pictures of each system.

    Discussion pause: Pairs write a benefit and a limit for each before sharing.

    In the lesson window

    • Think it through: For each of the three, name one clear benefit of automating it, and one situation in which it might not do what is wanted.
    • Apply it: The head teacher wants to use movement-sensing lights in a stairwell that is sometimes used by pupils walking in very dim light. Which is the best-justified comment?
    • Apply it: Months into the year, the lake in the volcano’s crater changes colour. The sensors measure only temperature and gas, so the automated system does not report it. What does this show?
    • Apply it: Which is the strongest advantage of the motion-sensing controller, for a player who finds pressing small buttons difficult?
  8. 7. Make a judgement Apply 12 min

    Purpose: Pupils see a worked method for judging whether to automate, then apply it to Tom’s sweeping claim and to a swimming-pool scenario with a conditional conclusion.

    Ask

    • What is the weakness in ‘every task that can be automated should be automated, because machines are cheaper’?
    • Write a judgement for automating the swimming pool: what would it do, what is gained, what could go wrong, and what do you recommend?

    Responses to expect

    • It ignores set-up cost, the jobs affected and what happens on failure, which differ between scenarios
    • A reasoned judgement that uses the scenario and ends with a condition

    Misconceptions to challenge

    • A learner may believe: “Cost is the only thing that matters in a decision.” Respond: Cost is one thing. Ask about safety, set-up cost and the effect on people.
    • A learner may believe: “Automated systems are always less accurate than people.” Respond: Many are more accurate and consistent; a fair judgement uses the facts of the scenario.
    • A learner may believe: “A good judgement says yes or no.” Respond: It names advantages and risks and ends with a condition, such as yes if there is a backup test.

    On the board or with the pen

    • Write the four steps and fill them in for the swimming pool as pupils contribute.

    What learners should notice

    • The worked example gives four steps: what it does, gains, risks, decision with a condition.

    Checking understanding: Collect the judgements; check each uses the scenario’s facts, names a risk and ends with a condition.

    Depending on the answers

    • If judgements are one-sided: ask for one risk if they praised and one benefit if they only criticised.
    • If answers are strong: ask pupils to swap and say what extra condition they would add to their partner’s judgement.

    Support

    • Offer the four-step frame with a sentence starter for each step.

    Stretch

    • Judge the same pool system for a very small primary school; which facts change your conclusion?

    English as an additional language

    • Allow a table with four rows instead of paragraphs.

    Discussion pause: Two minutes of silent writing for the judgement before pairs compare.

    In the lesson window

    • Apply it: Tom says: “Every task that can be automated should be automated, because machines are cheaper than people.” What is the weakness in this reasoning?
    • Think it through: A school wants to make its swimming pool automated: sensors measure the water temperature and chemicals, and a microprocessor adjusts the heating and the chemical pumps. Write a judgement on whether it is a good idea. Give one advantage, one disadvantage, and a conclusion that depends on the facts.
  9. 8. Show what you know Consolidate 8 min

    Purpose: Pupils explain how the three parts work in a chosen system, with one advantage and one risk, and order the loop, which shows whether they can describe the system, not just name its parts.

    Ask

    • Choose an automated system and explain how its sensor, microprocessor and actuator work together, with one advantage and one risk.
    • Which is the correct order of the loop?

    Responses to expect

    • Sensor measures, microprocessor compares and decides, actuator acts, and the loop repeats; with a real advantage and a real risk
    • The sensor measures, the microprocessor decides, the actuator acts, and then the sensor measures again

    Misconceptions to challenge

    • A learner may believe: “The actuator decides and the microprocessor moves.” Respond: The jobs are mixed up. Ask which part decides and which moves.
    • A learner may believe: “The decision comes after the action.” Respond: The decision must come before the action. Ask what tells the actuator what to do.

    On the board or with the pen

    • Collect three pupil systems with their sensor, microprocessor and actuator in a table.

    Checking understanding: Collect explanations; check all three parts, the loop repeating, and a risk specific to the system.

    Depending on the answers

    • If explanations name parts but not the loop: ask what happens after the actuator acts.
    • If answers are strong: ask what the system cannot detect and who would notice.

    Support

    • Offer a frame: The sensor ___. The microprocessor ___. The actuator ___.

    English as an additional language

    • Allow a labelled loop diagram with one sentence for the risk.

    Discussion pause: Two minutes of silent writing before pairs compare.

    In the lesson window

    • Think it through: Choose an automated system you have met in this lesson, or one of your own. Explain how its sensor, microprocessor and actuator work together, and say one advantage and one disadvantage of automating it.
    • Check your understanding: Which is the correct order of the loop in an automated system?
  10. Lesson recap Closing

    On screen: the lesson’s objectives again; Next adds the closing question, which asks the class to explain each one in their own words without looking back. It says nothing about what anyone has learnt: use the answers to decide what to revisit.

    Points to listen for

    • Ask pupils to draw the sense, process, act loop from memory for one system and mark where it could go wrong.
    • Take Tom’s claim and ask pupils to write a reply that agrees with part of it and corrects the rest.
    • Look ahead: robots combine automation with a body, so ask pupils what a robot has that a street light does not.
    • Ask pupils to name one automated system they have used this week and one thing it cannot do.

Consolidation

  • Ask pupils to draw the sense, process, act loop from memory for one system and mark where it could go wrong.
  • Take Tom’s claim and ask pupils to write a reply that agrees with part of it and corrects the rest.
  • Look ahead: robots combine automation with a body, so ask pupils what a robot has that a street light does not.
  • Ask pupils to name one automated system they have used this week and one thing it cannot do.